top of page

Big Bank Loyalty Costs Big Bucks

We all know that big banks, in particular, have gone rogue. It was after the Global Financial Crisis, that the funny business began. In 2013, author of How to Get Mortgage-Free Like Me, Nicole Pedersen-McKinnon, set out to catch the big four hoarding and hiking at whim, launching what she calls the Interest Integrity Index. Eight years in, what you overpay if you remain loyal to a big bank has leapt 134%…from $78,948 to $184,831.

That’s now more than twice the average annual wage of $89,000 or a Mercedes C 63 S luxury sedan! .

A huge number of Australians – 4 in 5 - hold the biggest cost-culprit, their mortgage, with a big four bank. They effectively throw that money away!

Where you could save the most money

Your home loan is where the interest ‘overtake’ is largest. My Interest Integrity Index looks at the difference between the big four-average interest rates on mortgages, personal loans and credit cards, and the best interest rate on the market. This difference is then applied to the average amount of each Aussies’ mortgage, personal loan and credit card debt - to deliver your precise dollar detriment.

The reality is most of us have a loan, mortgage or credit card throughout our lives. Which means the actual dosh you lose to the banks could be many times higher.

Mortgages account for almost all of the $184,831 lost in excess interest, according to the latest reading of the Index. All but $3,987 in fact.

This is partly because the average mortgage has spiked from $299,700 at the end of 2013 to $453,133 at the end of 2020 (from ABS Lending Indicators).

Research from Mozo, reveals the pricing premium borrowers pay with the big four has leapt from 1.42 points to 2.52 points. Worse, it’s jumped up from 2.21 points to that 2.52 level just over COVID (between October 2019 and December 2020)!

In 2013, the advertised big four variable home loan was priced 3.41 above the Reserve Bank official cash rate. Today it’s 4.41 (remember the cash rate has crashed down to a never-before-seen 0.1 %).

NAB deserves a special shout out for the past year, as it’s passed on more of the official cuts than any of the other big four. Even so, you’ll now pay $303,237 on the average advertised interest rate of a big bank, while huge discounting by other lenders means you could part with as little as $122,393 with the cheapest-on-market lender Reduce (for 80% loan-to-value loans).

How much extra you'll pay if you stay – on the average Aussies' debts

Source: Nicole Pedersen-McKinnon

Personal debt interest rates ratchet up

The credit card contribution to the Interest Integrity Index may be far smaller than the mortgage, but the big four average conventional card rate has done nothing but grow while our official rates have plummeted. It now stands at 18.79% against a market average from Mozo’s database of 16.87%. However, the lowest-rate comparable card on the market, G&C Mutual Bank's Low-Rate Visa Credit Card, charges just 7.49%. On the average debt, repaid at $100 a month, that’s a difference of $129.

The reason this is so low when the interest rate differential is so large is that Aussies have been admirably ditching their card debt, in one at least positive outcome of the COVID crisis.

Unfortunately, they’ve been signing up to ubiquitous buy-now-pay-later services at an equal pace.

On the personal loan front, for the average loan size search ($23,000) on Mozo’s website, you could be paying 5.35% with Australian Military Bank’s five-year fix as opposed to 11.17 percent with a big four alternative. The saving (as opposed to slug) would mount to $3858.

What can you do about it all?

First of all, never pay the interest rate a large lender advertises. As experienced finance brokers we know that – behind closed doors – an average interest rate discount of 92 basis points (taking the average rate to 3.59 percent)…and possibly more if you allow us to negotiate hard for you.

Don’t miss that you need to be signed up to a home loan package to access any discounts though, for which you’ll typically pay upwards of $400 a year. Also don’t be tricked by the big four bank’s rock-bottom fixed rates. These are designed to get you through the door and migrate you to their expensive variable rates..

The very best way to protect yourself and your bottom line is to simply to pick up the phone and ring us on 1300 861 143 to get sound advice.

Your Choice Mortgage Brokers Pty Ltd ATF Halo Innovation Trust trading as Heart Mortgage Services - Australian Credit Licence 38643.

The information contained herein is of a general nature only and does not constitute advice. You should not act on any information without considering your personal needs, circumstances and objectives. We recommend you obtain professional financial advice specific to your circumstances. The views expressed here are not ours. While the information contained in this article may contain or be based on information obtained from sources believed to be reliable, it may not have been independently verified. Where information contained in this publication contains material provided directly by third parties it is given in good faith and has been derived from sources believed to be accurate at its issue date. To the maximum extent permitted by law: no guarantee, representation or warranty is given that any information or advice in this publication is complete, accurate, up to date or fit for any purpose; and no party or associated entities as mentioned is in any way liable to you (including for negligence) in respect of any reliance upon such information. This article may also contain links to websites operated by third parties who are not related to us. These links are provided for convenience only and do not represent any endorsement or approval by us.

8 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page